File 004— A registry of verbal crimes —Pending, opened

Rhetoric & Logic

a free press   language is a virus

Bureau of Verbal Forensics · open file

Nancy Pelosi

File 004 · 9 Mar 2010 · Quote-mining · quote-mining

The famous line is real. The clause after it is also real. Neither saves the theory of government in the first half.

Exhibit A · Pass it to find out

Verdict · Quote-mining · quote-mining

National Association of Counties, 9 March 2010
We have to pass the bill so that you can find out what is in it, away from the fog of the controversy.

Rhetoric · The line is a dare. Procedure is offered as the path to knowledge. The audience is told that reading is what happens after the vote.

Logic · “We have to pass the bill so that you can find out what is in it” does not say the text was secret. It does say knowledge follows passage. A legislature that must enact a text in order to learn the text has inverted the order of the verbs. The fog clause is real. The order she gave is also real.

Source · National Association of Counties, 9 March 2010. Full sentence confirmed by Snopes.

Inverted consent
74